Showing posts with label Insider/Outsider. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Insider/Outsider. Show all posts

11/13/2007

QTT: Confessions of a Closet Catholic

Here is a portion of my questioning the text paper...

Part 1:

Although Littman presents both Catholicism as well as Judaic religious environments, there is room for discussion as to whether each was presented equally and free of biases. Does Littman provide an accurate depiction of both Catholicism and Judaism – is it possible that she may be favoring one over the other? This concern stems from numerous in class debates centered around this notion of authentic authors verses those who may not have first hand experiences. This on-going insider outsider debate is indisputably controversial and should be approached respectfully and open-mindedly to avoid assumptions as well as oversimplifications.

Part 2:

In the face of adversary from her family, Justine decides to investigate a different faith. On page 3 Justine explains that she wants to be like her best friend, Mac, who is Catholic. Again on pages 20 and 21 Justine presents rationale for desiring to become Catholic, “Weekly confession was just one of the reasons I decided to become Catholic. Here are some of the others: 1) I get to celebrate Christmas […] 2) I like the music […] 3) Catholic families are more normal than Jewish ones.” Pages 11 through 14 depict Justine’s first closet confession experience. She investigates Catholic practices on her own in her closet with her own representations of symbolic items from this religion. While wearing a cross necklace, Justine pretends to “look like a nun” with a white napkin on her head, participates in communion with grape juice and matzos, confesses her sins to “Father Ted,” her teddy bear, and recites Hail Mary on her rosemary. While this practice may be valid, I question where Justine learned these activities – what source is this information coming from? Justine attends mass with Mac which serves as the first factual representation of the Catholic faith. Due to her lack of knowledge concerning the events of mass, Justine walks away with a possibly skewed image of this faith.

In terms of Jewish culture and religion, Justine is influenced mainly by the lifestyles of her grandmother Bubbe, and the Weinstein’s. As mentioned previously, Justine is exploring the idea of being more committed to her faith; becoming more connected with her Jewish roots. It is clear that Justine receives information about Judaism from her Jewish family, which makes these ideas more authentic as a reader. The text is packed full of references, information, and even Yiddish and Hebrew terms that further influence readers view of this culture. As Justine compares and contrasts Catholic customs with that of her Jewish ones, it is debatable that readers are generally exposed to more authentic representations of Judaism in light of the family’s rich surplus of information and experiences.

Part 3

The issue of accurate representations, in this case in reference to religion, is not an easy matter, nor does it have a simple solution. Jacqueline Woodson’s article “Who Can Tell My Story?” emphasizes the importance writers experiencing events they write about. In reference to her partner’s religion she explains, “It is not my house, nor will it ever be, but there are elements we share” (44). No matter what stand you take on the insider/ outsider debate, as teachers it is unavoidable that we will face the task of discerning quality writing from poor writing. We should concentrate on universal ties that we share instead of the differences that pull us a part.

9/17/2007

Insider/Outsider Debate - Multicultural Literature

"Diversity without equity is not the goal of multiculturalism." -Mingshui Cai

As Cai mentions in his article Multiple Definitions of Multicultural Literature: Is the Debate Really Just "Ivory Tower" Bickering? this debate directly affects teachers in that we are an integral part of maintaining goals of providing a multicultural education. I personally am having a lot of conflicts when reading the articles for class because I feel as though there is a lot of tension between the authors and not much unity on the subject. This is not an easy debate nor does it have a correct answer. Overall I lean towards the notion that an insider can best represent his or her own culture, whether that is a racial, religious, sexual orientation, socioeconomic class, education, or any other element of multicultural literature. That does not exclude those who are educated in other cultures different from their own or those who have close relations with those various cultures. I would like to think of it as an issue of expertise – just as a doctor who specializes in optometry would not perform surgery on the foot or similarly a dermatologist would not be best to recommend joint pain medications, I would prefer the right man for the right job. As Bishop explains, an African American is most likely more fit for the job of writing African American literature due to the fact that “it is the way they have been acculturated.”

I question Shannon’s basis for many of his claims as well as how he can assume such things like in the second paragraph where he states:

More often, however, they [female, white educators in the rural and suburban school districts] see the debate as irrelevant to their teaching and lives because they work (or will work) in rural and suburban school districts which as isolated and safe from “the crisis” of multicultural metropolitan areas. (Shannon 1)

Since I nearly fit his description of such a (future) female educator, I am confused as to how someone could actually feel that this debate is unsafe as well as distant. This seems to me to be a very narrow view of the world, almost as if they (those white females he is depicting) desire this sheltered isolation. Shannon presents to his readers the idea that Rudine Sims Bishop “reduces multiculturalism to issues of race” when in fact he is taking her literally and out of context, which she defends in her article – she simply identifies best with the racial aspect of multiculturalism and therefore discusses that topic most often. She is not in anyway denying that there are other functions of multicultural literature.

It is also critical to have a working definition of culture. I feel this includes any and all aspects of your individual life. Each experience you have shapes you into who you are which can be seen in your values, racial orientation, sexual preference, and other such dimensions of your life. It is important as future teachers to be on guard and watchful of fallacies within literature in order to prevent misconceptions, stereotypes, and other such uneducated pieces of literature to enter our classrooms. Being a critical reader will be an important tool when deciding if an author correctly represents the culture as a whole.